Recommendations to the foreign financiers of Argentina's lithium rush
To realise the energy transition, large quantities of minerals and metals such as lithium, cobalt and rare earth metals are needed. These raw materials are mainly extracted in countries in the global South, and unfortunately this is almost always accompanied by human rights violations and environmental destruction. Today – also in light of EU Raw Materials Week that is happening this week – Argentinian organisation FARN and Both ENDS publish a joint report on the extraction of lithium in Argentina.
How can we ensure that people and nature are not harmed by the extraction of raw materials for our energy transition? Is it wise to provide export support to companies entering this market? Using the Argentinian case, the report attempts to answer these and other obvious dilemmas surrounding the extraction of transition minerals. Marius Troost is one of the authors of the report and gives us some insight.
Why did FARN and Both ENDS decide this was an urgent matter to touch upon?
Marius: "Making the transition from fossil fuels to renewables is priority number one. Yet we tend to forget that our clean energy supply needs resources as well. These will also have to be extracted somewhere, bearing in mind that mining has a tremendous impact wherever it takes place. We are seeing an increased interest by businesses and governments in securing our so-called 'transition minerals', including interest by Export Credit Agencies (ECAs – see box) from the Global North. With this report, we show which governments and ECAs are already financing the lithium sector in Argentina and the impacts this has on people and environment. "
What is so damaging about lithium extraction?
"Lithium extraction requires tremendous amounts of water in places - like the salt flats - where water is extremely scarce. This comes at the cost of drinking water and agriculture. It also has severe impacts for the fragile ecosystems in the area. What's more, lithium mining in Argentina still has a very extractivist character and reinforces the unequal distribution of wealth and the unequal trade balance between North and South"
What is the main conclusion of the report?
"We are already seeing Export Credit Agencies move into the lithium sector in Argentina. Foreign companies active in the sector are supported to undertake their business activities. At this point it's the Canadian and the Korean ECAs, but we will surely see more interest in the future. Unfortunately, the communities of the High Andean wetlands where the lithium extraction is taking place, do not at all benefit. They only suffer the significant environmental impacts and human rights violations."
How can we turn the tide, what should be done internationally?
"First and foremost, the global North should look critically at its own energy and material consumption. I mean: replacing our entire fleet of petrol-powered cars with electric ones is simply not a realistic option, as resources like lithium are limited too and the extraction will come at the cost of communities in the global South. We should really also think about less cars, rather than alternative cars. At the same time, international businesses and governments should take care to guarantee environmental and human rights. They should carefully consult the local communities and respect their 'right to say no' to projects on their land."
Who should definitely read this report?
"The EU is currently working on finalising its Critical Raw Materials Act. And globally, businesses and ECAs are eager to move into the raw materials space. The report has practical recommendations on how to go about this – we hope it will help them make informed policies that use a human rights and environment centred approach."
Export Credit Agencies and Investment Insurance Agencies, commonly known as ECAs, are public agencies that provide government-backed loans, guarantees, credits and insurance to private corporations from their home country.
ECAs make it easier for those corporations to do business abroad, particularly in the financially and politically risky developing world. Most industrialised nations have at least one ECA, which is usually an official or quasi-official branch of their government.
For more information
Read more about this subject
-
Dossier /
Towards a socially and environmentally just energy transition
To address the climate crisis we need to urgently transition away from fossil fuels towards clean, renewable energy. However, this transition is not only about changing energy sources. It requires an inclusive and fair process that tackles systemic inequalities and demanding consumption patterns…
-
Publication / 13 November 2023
-
External link / 2 July 2024
-
News / 20 February 2023
Almost 60 organisations send a letter about fossil export support to Dutch Parliament
Today, a letter, undersigned by almost 60 organisations from countries that face the consequences of fossil fuel projects or stand in solidarity, has been sent to the Dutch Members of Parliament. This Thursday, a debate about the export credit facility and the policies around it, will take place in the Dutch Parliament. The coalition calls upon Dutch politicians and policy makers to stand up against any form of export support for fossil fuel projects that are…
-
Letter / 28 February 2023
175 CSOs call on world leaders to end OECD export finance for oil and gas
This joint position launched by 175 civil society organisations from 45 countries calls on world leaders to end OECD export finance for oil and gas, and explains how it can be done.
-
Publication / 15 March 2023
-
News / 25 January 2024
'We can not have a transition when we do not talk about consumption patterns'
The parliamentary elections in the Netherlands are over, and the dust has somewhat settled. No matter what government emerges from the process, one thing is clear: in the Netherlands the main focus is on the Netherlands. Foreign affairs were hardly mentioned during the elections and the same applies to the process of forming a new coalition. More alarmingly, some of the winners in the elections want to cut themselves off even further from…
-
News / 29 January 2024
Five climate projects of 2024 in a nutshell
Together with environmental justice groups from the Global South, Both ENDS works towards a sustainable, fair and inclusive world. Both ENDS gathers and shares information about policy and investments that have a direct impact on people and their livelihood, we engage in joint advocacy, we…
-
News / 26 April 2024
Communities Urgent Warning Ahead of Vale S.A.’s Annual Meeting: Stop Ongoing Abuses of People and Environment
As shareholders in Brazilian mining giant Vale S.A prepare to gather online for the company’s Annual General Meeting (AGM), communities from Brazil to Indonesia criticize the company’s track record on human rights and environmental stewardship. They also point to the almost $50 billion in mounting…
-
Letter / 8 December 2024
People and the Planet Entebbe Declaration: Reclaiming investment frameworks for people and the planet
The time for change is now. Civil society demands international investment
frameworks that are aligned with economic justice, social and environmental
sustainability, and the needs of communities worldwide. -
Blog / 30 January 2025
Brumadinho’s painful “seas of mud”
By Carolina de Moura
Six years ago, Brumadinho tailings dam I, from the Paraopeba Complex, owned by mining company Vale, collapsed. January 25th, 2019, forever changed the lives of thousands. The scars remain open, and the quest for justice, remembrance, and prevention of future mining crimes endures despite all adversities. This was manslaughter coupled with socio-environmental devastation of proportions difficult to measure. These are irreparable losses and damages that could have been avoided if it wasn’t for the greed, negligence, and irresponsibility of decision-makers at Vale, the German…
-
News / 26 November 2024
The Time to Rethink Investment Rules: Amplifying Civil Society Voices
At the core of the Fair, Green, and Global (FGG) Alliance’s mission is the commitment to building a just and sustainable world. As members of this alliance, Both ENDS, SOMO, and the Transnational Institute (TNI) recognise the urgent need to reimagine global investment frameworks. These frameworks, entrenched in outdated treaties such as Bilateral Investment Treaties (BITs) and the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT), often prioritise…
-
News / 4 April 2024
EU ECA fossil fuel phase-out tracker reveals EU Member States’ lagging commitment to Paris Agreement goals in export credit policies
Our new report titled EU ECA fossil fuel phase-out tracker by Both ENDS, Counter Balance and Oil Change International sheds light on the concerning lack of harmony between EU Member States' export credit climate policies. …
-
News / 3 October 2024
CVM trial of Vale Executives over Brumadinho Dam Collapse brings new momentum
Fabio Schvartsman and Gerd Peter Poppinga attended a Securities and Exchange Commission (CVM) trial session, last Tuesday, October 1st. Poppinga was convicted by one of the CMV directors, but the second CMV director requested more time to review the case files, postponing the judgment by 60…
-
Press release / 29 August 2022
Billions of euros a year in support for fossil exports underscores importance of Glasgow Declaration
Amsterdam, 29 August 2022 - A recent study by Both ENDS shows that, in the past decade, the Dutch government has provided on average a billion euros a year in insurance for fossil energy projects. At the end of last year, together with 33 other countries, the Netherlands agreed to stop providing this support by the end of 2022. Both ENDS calls on the government to formulate a resolute policy that leaves no room for exemptions that contribute…
-
News / 24 January 2024
Both ENDS in solidarity with Justice for Brumadinho!
272 innocent people were killed. A tsunami of toxic mud unleashed, some 12 million cubic metres of ore tailing into the surrounding areas. January…
-
Press release / 9 March 2023
Dutch Pension funds do not vote in line with climate ambitions
Authors note rectification 13 April 2023
Most Dutch pension funds and their asset managers do not vote consistently in favour of climate resolutions at the oil and gas companies and banks in which they invest. That is the conclusion of a report published today by Both ENDS and Groen Pensioen. Eleven of the twelve* Dutch pension funds studied have made public statements and pledges about adapting their policies in line with the Paris Climate Agreement. But their voting behaviour…
-
Publication / 8 March 2023
-
Press release / 3 November 2022
The Netherlands breaks major climate promise to end public financing for international fossil fuel projects
Today, a week before the international climate summit in Egypt, the Dutch Government has broken a major climate promise it made last year to end public financing for international fossil fuel projects. International and Dutch NGOs argue that the new policy published by the Dutch Government on…
-
News / 25 November 2024