Both ENDS

News / 9 November 2024

Why is the Dutch climate case against Shell important to our partners in the Global South?

On November 12th, a new ruling will be issued by the Court of Appeal in The Hague in the climate case against Shell, in which Both ENDS is a co-plaintiff. Ahead of this ruling, we asked our partners why this Dutch lawsuit is important for the Global South.

ALY SAGNE - Director Lumière Synergie pour le Développement - Senegal

"We care about our land, water and our lives. So, holding Shell to account for its climate legacy matters for the African people too."

FATOUMATA MBODJI - Communication and Advocacy officer Lumière Synergie pour le Développement - Senegal

"Together, we can ensure that the big oil companies can no longer escape their environmental responsibilities. We firmly believe that this case against Shell is an essential step for climate justice."

ALEJANDRO MEITÍN - Founder of Casa Río Lab

“The Shell oil spill, which occurred 25 years ago in the Río de la Plata, Argentina, is considered the largest freshwater disaster of its kind. This environmental event had a devastating impact on riparian ecosystems and the communities that depend on them. However, to date, Shell has not faced any penalties for its responsibility. We believe that a conviction in international instances could demonstrate forcefully that the value of justice prevails in defense of life and the environment." (Translated from Spanish)

WOMEN IN ACTION ON MINING IN ASIA (WAMA)

"WAMA (Women in Action on Mining in Asia), a regional solidarity alliance raising the voices of women affected by extractive industries, strongly condems the long-standing human rights violations against the Ogoni people of Nigeria, who have been protecting their biodiversity-rich land and natural resources from environmental destruction. We have observed the suffering of our Ogoni sisters whose voices have been repeatedly suppressed by military actions. Acts of violence, unjust trials, and unimaginable cruelty against the indigenous people of Nigeria were and are, overtly and covertly, a result of Shell’s overarching power over the government and its military dictatorship.

Women and children have suffered the most, losing their health, families, access to food, and safety. The continued intimidation and violence against women must be stopped immediately. A fair trial by the International Tribunal is extremely important for the Ogoni, who have no hope for justice in their own country.

Shell operations are not only causing human rights violations but are also seriously harming the climate with emissions from their oil and gas extraction. While the Dutch government is spending public funds to combat the climate crisis, Dutch companies like Shell are destroying ecosystems and indigenous communities that take care of these ecosystems.

We, the inidenous, pastoral, rural women of Asia, demand that Shell immediately stop its environmental destruction, reduce its emissions by 45 percent, and phase out oil and gas. We appeal to the honorable court and the government of the Netherlands to intervene, halt the crimes of Shell, and uphold the principles of international human rights and the laws of Mother Earth."

FLORENCIA ORTÚZAR GREENE - Attorney Asociación Interamericana para la
Defensa del Ambiente (AIDA)

"Thank you, colleagues, for your courage in leading this strategic case against Shell, which addresses the root causes of climate injustice. Cases like this offer hope and strengthen the international movement working tirelessly for a just and peaceful world."

ARYAMPA BRIGHTON - Youth for Green Communities (YGC) - Uganda

"Solving the climate crisis is the greatest and most complex challenge that we have ever faced. But the main solution is simple, we must stop our emissions of greenhouse gases and hold major polluters accountable for the ongoing human rights abuses and livelihood disruptions. This case pronouncement is timely and important to emphasize strict adherence to Paris agreement and imposing legal obligations on shell and other major polluters."

We at Both ENDS would like to thank all partners who answered our call and send in their quotes.

Read more about this subject