Both ENDS visit Tweede Kamer to talk about destructiveness of dredging worldwide
This week several Both ENDS colleagues visit Tweede Kamer der Staten-Generaal to meet Christine Teunissen and Luc Stultiens with partners from Mozambique, Indonesia and the Filippines to talk about the destructiveness of dredging worldwide and especially in projects with the aid of the Dutch government.
Read their plea
Niels - Introduction
Thank you chairman and thank you to the members of parliament for your interest to hear stories from the ground about the negative impacts of export credits for the dredging sector.
Last Monday, we, 4 Dutch and 6 international civil society organisations, published the report Dredging destruction that you see in front of you. It reveals how Dutch dredging companies are systematically destroying human lives and the environment around the world with the help of taxpayers’ money. Between 2012 and 2023, The Netherlands provided 8.4 billion euros in insurance for dredging projects by Boskalis and Van Oord around the world. This is 32% of the total insured value. These projects are destroying human lives and the environment. The Dutch government’s policy to protect people and planet is failing systemically. After twelve years of studies and talking with Dutch ministries, Atradius and the dredging companies, there are no real improvements. It is time for a thorough clean-up of Dutch governmental support for the dredging sector.
Now you will hear from my colleagues Julio Ernesto from Mozambique, Muhammad Al Amin from Indonesia and Maria Sol Taule from the Philippines. Their organisations, like the other co-authors of the report, represent thousands of farmers and fisherfolk that have bore the brunt of large-scale dredging projects. In Cabo Del Gado Mozambique, the Dutch government awarded an insurance against the background of an unprecedentedly violent conflict that has displaced hundred of thousands of people. In Makassar, the Netherlands awarded an insurance to a project that resulted in the widespread destruction of marine ecosystems and fishing livelihoods. In Manila, the Netherlands has awarded an insurance to the New Manila International Airport that displaced hundreds of families in a context of one of the most repressive and violent regimes towards human rights activists, culminating in the abduction of two activists by armed forces in September 2023 who advocating for the rights of communities impacted by the airport project.
Amin’s talking point on the Dutch Parliament and Minister
Thank you for the opportunity to speak with you behalf of the communities of Galesong, Takalar Indonesia. On this very excellent meeting, I would like to convey several things, especially how the fishermen and coastal women have been affected by the sea sand dredging project of Boskalis supported by the Dutch government.
The Boskalis dredging project in Indonesia was finished in 2017, but the impacts are still experienced by the community today, especially traditional fishermen and women. The most serious impact of this project is the eviction of 43 families at the reclamation site. Their homes and livelihoods were destroyed. They didn’t receive any compensation. Atradius didn’t consider these families to be living in the project area of Boskalis, however this is not true. They had to leave their homes and fishing grounds for a mosque and fancy houses to be build for the project. Boskalis also caused impacts to the marine ecosystem due to the sea sand dredging. Until now, thousands of traditional fishermen are still catching less fish then before the project was carried out. This is due to the destruction of the marine ecosystem, as fishermen depend on this ecosystem for their fishing areas. Now with climate change, the situation for the fishermen is getting even worse as the marine ecosystem served as a natural barrier against heavy waves. This natural barrier is now broken. Due to less fish catches and damaged houses, many fishermen had to migrate and become fishing boat laborers with a small income of 3 EUR per day.
In 2019, the Galesong fishermen and coastal women represented by WALHI South Sulawesi and Both ENDS filed a complaint to Atradius for their involvement in the project. The communities wish to receive support from the Dutch government to restore their livelihoods by creating new opportunities to fish in a traditional way, as they have been doing for generations. Also, we request Atradius and the Dutch government to change its social and environmental policies to prevent damages in the future. After a very long process, almost 5 years, the complaint process is almost finished. I request you to follow the results of this complaint closely and make sure the recommendations are implemented.
In conclusion, learning from the impact of the sand dredging project Makassar in 2017, this project is very destructive to vulnerable communities.
On behalf of the communities affected by the sand dredging project insured by Dutch public money (taxes of the Dutch people), I ask you to:
- Assist affected communities by sea sand dredging projects via livelihood restoration programs.
- Improve the social and environmental policy of Atradius to prevent environmental impacts, human rights violations, and impoverishment of vulnerable communities
- Ensure that the social and environmental safeguard policies of Atradius are properly implemented.
Speech Julio
It is with great concern and sadness that I address this session, where everyone is well dressed and wearing suits under a nice building and air conditioning with all kinds of technology, while at the moment there are many children, women and people with disabilities who are starving and living in real misery, without a home, school or basic health services, and many people, populations are dying because of terrorism in Cabo Delgado, in the face of this the Dutch government and its companies are only concerned with exploiting the natural resources of my province!
I feel that developed countries, including the Netherlands, are taking advantage of the financial vulnerability of poor countries, offering disproportionate contracts to continue impoverishing poor countries, exploiting their resources through fabricated policies and narratives, as is happening in my country. Furthermore, the Dutch government seems to me to be running away from its responsibilities and throwing all the blame at the poor countries it calls its partners.
In 2019, we issued some recommendations on gender issues and other aspects in relation to the activities of Dutch companies involved in the Rovuma basin LNG project and we have yet to see any results from them.
In 2019, Atradius, the Dutch export credit agency, visited my region, Cabo Delgado, to carry out a socio-environmental and safety assessment so that your companies, like Van Oord, could receive its insurance and support. But the team that did this work went to the project area with a helicopter and bulletproof vests.
How can a team that wants to carry out a socio-environmental and safety assessment go into the field equipped like that? What results do you think this team could bring to report on the real situation in the region? Just to see, two years after that assessment, we had the situation of the occupation by terrorists in the town of Palma and other neighboring districts in the project area. Total evacuated its team, but the population was besieged and many of them were killed.
This shows that your lives are worth more than those of the people of that region, who are the real owners of the wealth you want to exploit. However, the Netherlands and the whole of Europe boast that they are the great defenders of human rights, but don't those people who are suffering and losing their lives have the right to live like you?
Furthermore, the conclusion of the proximities report, the assessment at the request of the Dutch parliament that will be published in 2022, stated that Atradius did not have the expertise for a safety assessment and Atradius ignored recommendations given by civil society in my country, for example the UPC, my organization. At the moment Atradius is re-evaluating the project and we are extremely concerned that the Proximities recommendations are not being implemented.
Dear Dutch parliamentarians, we have noticed the contracts you impose when investing in poor countries in the global south, especially in Africa. For example in the LNG project in the Rovuma basin, the balance weighs more heavily on the more developed countries to the detriment of the benefits for Mozambique, since TotalEnergies itself and its creditors stand to gain the most from this project.
Ladies and gentlemen, to conclude, I would like to know if you would be satisfied if Mozambicans came to your country to exploit resources, under the hypocritical conditions that you impose on us. Would you like it? Or do you think that Mozambicans are not human? Please let's show more solidarity when it comes to exploiting natural resources.
Niels - Conclusions and recommendations of the report
Chairman, in my 8 years experience at Both ENDS I have heard these stories over and over. And they still make me feel sick to my stomach. I can see these stories have also made an impression on you and the parliamentarians here today. Then how can it be that the Dutch government and the dredging companies don’t take action?
In 2018 a motion from the parliamentarians Alkaya and Van Raan (nr 26 485) was accepted that tried to break through the systemic failures. It requested the government to ensure that any application for export credit insurance is rejected when the risks of human rights violations or environmental damage are too high, regardless of the level playing field and the impact on applicant companies. This motion is clearly not put in practice. What do you think about that?
For those cases where the damage is done we request repairs, like in Makassar. In three of the seven cases described in our report, there is still the opportunity to do the right thing while the project is ongoing. These projects are bringing nothing but destruction to the communities and environment. We therefore call on you to urge the Dutch government to STOP the export credit support for the projects in Mozambique, the Philippines and the Maldives.
We must also think ahead in order to prevent any new export credit support for destructive dredging projects. Therefore we call on you and your legislative power to ensure alignment with the OECD guidelines, UN Guiding Principles, Biodiversity Frameworks and Sustainable Development Goals.
Concrete measures that should be taken are:
- Strong implementation of the social and environmental policy of Atradius;
- Adjusting the policy to
- ensure public disclosure of all relevant environmental and human rights documentation and
- ensure proper community consultations in which they are aware about the involvement of Dutch dredging companies and Atradius.
- include a gender policy to assess and manage gender-specific adverse impacts
- Reject requests for export credit support for projects that are planned in areas of high biodiversity importance, including in ecosystems of high ecological integrity.
- Reject requests for export credit support for projects that have already been associated with human rights abuses or illegal environmental destruction.
For more information
Read more about this subject
-
Dossier /
Gas in Mozambique
In 2011 one of the world’s largest gas reserves was found in the coastal province of Cabo Delgado, in the north of Mozambique. A total of 35 billion dollars has been invested to extract the gas. Dozens of multinationals and financiers are involved in these rapid developments. It is very difficult for the people living in Cabo Delgado to exert influence on the plans and activities, while they experience the negative consequences. With the arrival of these companies, they are losing their land.
-
Press release / 24 March 2024
Dredging destruction; worldwide research into Dutch dredgers
Dredging Destruction: Report reveals how Dutch dredging companies are systematically destroying human lives and the environment around the world with the help of taxpayers’ money
The Netherlands is providing billions of euros in support for dredging projects by Boskalis and Van Oord around the world. All of these projects are destroying human lives and the environment. The Dutch government’s policy to protect people and planet is failing systemically. And after twelve years of studies and talking, there are no real improvements. It is time for a thorough clean-up of government support for the dredging sector.
-
News / 29 May 2024
Serious questions about possible Dutch export support for Mozambique's LNG gas project
Members of Parliament Daniëlle Hirsch (PVDA-GL) and Christine Teunissen (PVDD) ask serious questions about possible Dutch export support for the Mozambique LNG gas project. Both ENDS has been advocating for the file for years.
-
News / 3 July 2024
-
News / 18 June 2024
Dutch government threatens to put human lives at risk again in infamous TotalEnergies gas project in Mozambique
The Dutch government threatens to blunder again by providing export support for TotalEnergies' controversial gas project in Cabo Delgado, Mozambique. This follows from an analysis of 9000 documents from FOI requests, commissioned by Milieudefensie and Both ENDS. Anne de Jonghe, Both ENDS: “When the export support was issued in 2021, critical voices were minimized, while TotalEnergies was heard and trusted. That should not happen again."
-
News / 16 August 2024
Statement on the denial of legal protection by the Philippines Court of Appeals towards environmental defenders Jonila Castro and Jhed Tamano
Both ENDS expresses its profound concern over the recent decision by the Philippines Court of Appeals to deny legal protection to Jonila Castro and Jhed Tamano against unlawful harassment and reprisals from state forces. Castro and Jhed are two young environmental human rights defenders who were violently abducted by Filipino armed forces in September 2023, for almost 17 days, in a case that made international headlines. The two women had been working as community organizers in Northern Manila Bay, where large-scale land reclamation's have wreaked havoc on communities and ecosystems.
-
News / 21 July 2020
Is the Netherlands insuring a controversial gas extraction project in Mozambique?
At the end of last week, oil and gas company Total announced that, through its export credit insurer Atradius DSB, the Dutch government is participating in a funding package for a controversial gas extraction project in Mozambique. The project, in which various Dutch and foreign companies are involved, is having a deep impact on the local population and the natural environment in the area. Which Dutch companies the government will be insuring is not yet clear.
-
Press release / 19 May 2021
Despite violence, 900 million euros in Dutch export support to Van Oord in Mozambique
Amsterdam, 19 May 2021 – On 25 March, a day after violent attacks in northern Mozambique, the Dutch state decided to provide dredging company Van Oord with export credit insurance worth 900 million euros for its activities in the country. The company is conducting dredging operations for a highly controversial gas project that, according to Mozambican interest groups, is playing a prominent role in the escalating violence in the region. Civil society organisations Both ENDS, Milieudefensie and Oil Change International and their Mozambican partners are alarmed about the situation and have called the Dutch government and Dutch export credit agency Atradius DSB to account.
-
Event / 26 October 2023, 20:00
Debate: Fossil disaster in Mozambique
In 2021, the Dutch government provided a €1.000.000.000,- worth export credit support to Totals Mozgas project in Cabo Delgado, despite civil society warnings about human rights and environmental risks. The gas exploitation fueled a violent conflict, culminating in the Palma attack, displacing 800,000 people and killing 1,200 people.
-
Event / 22 March 2023, 09:00 - 11:00
Towards just water governance in Colombia; a dialogue on the Transformative Water Pact
Online side event at the UN Water conference in New York
This event will present The Transformative Water Pact (TWP), an innovative framework for water governance that has been developed by environmental justice experts from around the world. The TWP will serve as a starting point for dialogue between representatives of the government of Colombia, academia, regional and international NGOs in relation to Colombia's current ambitions in multi-scalar water governance.
-
Transformative Practice /
A Negotiated Approach for Inclusive Water Governance
A Negotiated Approach envisages the meaningful and long-term participation of communities in all aspects of managing the water and other natural resources on which their lives depend. It seeks to achieve healthy ecosystems and equitable sharing of benefits among all stakeholders within a river basin. This inclusive way of working is an essential precondition for the Transformative Practices that are promoted by Both ENDS and partners.
-
News / 22 January 2024
Is the Netherlands’ reputation as a world leader in the field of water knowledge deserved?
The Netherlands is a major player in the global water sector, but our investments can quite often lead to human rights violations and environmental problems in the countries where they are made. What can a new Dutch government do to reduce the Netherlands’ footprint beyond our borders? Ellen Mangnus spoke to various experts about this issue: today, part 3.
-
News / 1 April 2021
Gas extraction worsened already dire situation in the North of Mozambique
Both ENDS is shocked by the dramatic news in the past days coming from Palma, Cabo Delgado, Mozambique. Our thoughts go to those who lost their lives or who are still missing, and their loved ones. Both ENDS is in close contact with our local partners to support them wherever we can. Many people are still missing, among whom members of farmers union UPC.
-
External link / 17 November 2021
Stop export support for fossil fuel project in Mozambique
Julio Bichehe Erneste of Farmers Union Cabo Delgado Mozambique (UPC) on a side event of COP26 in Glasgow, speaking about the negative impacts of export support for fossil fuel projects for local people and their enrironment, and about the need to support renewable energy projects instead.
-
External link / 24 June 2023
Women’s land rights in Mozambique (Annual Report 2022)
In Mozambique, few women can rest assured that their right to use and enjoy land is guaranteed. Forum Mulher, a network of Mozambican women's rights organisations, raised public awareness and mobilised rural women to effectively make their voices heard during the government's formal review of the legislative framework for land governance. As a result, the revised National Land Policy of Mozambique now emphasises the importance of prioritising and valuing rural peasant women in land policy and law.
-
Press release / 20 March 2023
A Transformative Water Pact : A radical response to the global water governance crisis
Academics and civil society representatives from around the world came together to articulate an alternative vision and framework for water governance, in the run-up to the UN Water Conference 2023 in New York. The Transformative Water Pact was developed in response to the continued exploitation of nature, neglect of human rights and the extreme power-imbalances that characterize contemporary water governance throughout the world. It details an alternative vision of water governance based on the tenets of environmental justice, equality and care.
-
Publication / 4 October 2019
-
Publication / 21 March 2023
-
News / 21 March 2023
Agua es vida: Both ENDS and water governance
Water is literally life, the lifeblood of ecosystems, of nature, of humans. However, in many places the distribution and use of water is unjust and unsustainable. Water management is generally focused on short-term economic interests, on maximizing the profit of a well-connected few at the expense of people and nature. This dominant view of water and water management has its origins in the European industrial revolution, which became the global norm through colonialism and globalization. But according to Melvin van der Veen and Murtah Shannon, water experts at Both ENDS, this view will have to give way to equitable, sustainable and inclusive water management. Both ENDS cooperates with and supports communities and organisations worldwide who are working to this end.
-
News / 14 June 2021
Concerns about a new airport in vulnerable Manila Bay
In Manila Bay, a vulnerable coastal area next to the Philippine capital city, a new airport is being planned, with involvement of the Dutch water sector. Local civil society organisations raised their concerns about this airport, which has large impact on the lives of local residents and on the ecosystem.